• Latest
  • All
The circular (un)reasoning of gender ideology

The circular (un)reasoning of gender ideology

January 20, 2022
Defects, limitations and differences: an essential key to family harmony

Defects, limitations and differences: an essential key to family harmony

November 28, 2023
Most important meeting of pro-family leaders in 2023 held at the UN

Most important meeting of pro-family leaders in 2023 held at the UN

November 28, 2023
Priest attacked in Santiago de Compostela Cathedral

Priest attacked in Santiago de Compostela Cathedral

November 27, 2023
YouTube Screenshot edited in Canva

More than 30,000 lives saved from abortion since SCOTUS overturned Roe in June 2022

November 10, 2023
Love in the contemporary world (II)

Love in the contemporary world (II)

November 10, 2023
ARC conference: A new vision for future, a better story for our children

ARC conference: A new vision for future, a better story for our children

November 9, 2023
Spain: Pro-abortion activists attack a church in Barcelona

Spain: Pro-abortion activists attack a church in Barcelona

November 8, 2023
The irony: Freedom of Expression Rapporteur calls for censorship of conservative views

The irony: Freedom of Expression Rapporteur calls for censorship of conservative views

November 6, 2023
Students protest over drag event at the University of Notre Dame

Students protest over drag event at the University of Notre Dame

October 29, 2023
Uterus transplantation for transgenders under study

Uterus transplantation for transgenders under study

October 29, 2023
  • About iFamNews
  • Contact

Navigation Button Subscribe

  • Subscribe
November 29, 2023
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
  • English
    • Italiano
    • Español
    • Français
    • Deutsch
    • Polski
    • српски
    • Русский

Navigation Button Donate

  • Donate
International Family News Network (IFN)
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Life
  • Family
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Shows
  • Petitions
  • Subscribe
  • Donate
International Family News Network (IFN)
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Life
  • Family
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Shows
  • Petitions
  • Subscribe
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
International Family News Network (IFN)
No Result
View All Result

The circular (un)reasoning of gender ideology

Because trans activists are unable to define their terms, none of the rest of us are allowed to define ours.

Joseph Grabowski by Joseph Grabowski
January 20, 2022
in Entertainment, Opinion
954
Reading Time: 3 mins read
0
The circular (un)reasoning of gender ideology
Share on FacebookShare on WhatsAppShare on TelegramShare on TwitterShare on WeChat

In a recent segment of the Dr. Phil show, conservative blogger Matt Walsh appeared alongside two transgender individuals in what was touted as a presentation of “both sides of the gender pronoun debate.”

Walsh recently shared part of this exchange on Twitter. In the clip, he is responding to a prior statement by one of the other guests, Addison Rose Vincent (of Break the Binary LLC), that “Trans-women are women.”

Walsh’s riposte is quite simple: he challenges the other guest to define the term “woman,” which they utterly fail to do. Watch below:

Here’s the part on Dr Phil where I demonstrate that the “gender experts” cannot even define the word woman or explain what they mean when they use it

pic.twitter.com/7CGcaEUlnj

— Matt Walsh (@MattWalshBlog) January 19, 2022

The full segment is available on Dr. Phil’s YouTube page.

The exchange is quite useful in pointing out the many ways that transgender ideology engages in a form of circular ‘reasoning’ that can barely be called logic at all; really, it is a form of doublespeak. Refusing to define “woman,” they render meaningless whatever they’re trying to say by the statement that “trans-women are women”.

Walsh says at the end of the clip that what his opponents are trying to do is “appropriate” the term “women” and the concept of “womanhood” and “turn it into basically a costume that can be worn.”

But it’s even worse that that, because even a costume has signifiers, content, and meaning. Think about it: if a child comes to your door at Halloween dressed in an “Incredible Hulk” costume, it’s probably unnecessary to ask they child what he is dressed up as; but suppose you do ask. And then the kid says, “I’m a Fireman!”

You’d probably be a bit confused; or, more accurately, you’d rightly assume that the child is confused.

What trans ideologues are really doing isn’t merely “appropriating” womanhood. Rather, they are utterly vitiating the term of its content and meaning, which is far worse. Acts of appropriation may be insensitive, or even offensive and demeaning… but at least they don’t pretend the appropriated concept doesn’t exist. But trans ideology really does pretend “womanhood” essentially doesn’t exist. Trans ideology doesn’t just appropriate what it means to be a woman, it seeks to erase women.

Both of Walsh’s interlocutors in the clip above say they cannot themselves define womanhood—that it’s not for them to say, that it looks different for everybody. To the unwary viewer (which apparently many of the applauding fools in the audience are), this might come off as a very intellectually humble and generous disavowal. It’s akin to the magnanimity of Socrates: wisest in Athens, on account of his knowing enough to recognize that there were some things he did not know.

But really, in this case, this is an statement of remarkable aggression and pride. By asserting that, whatever womanhood is, it’s “different for everybody,” trans activists don’t just disavow their own ability to define “woman;” in fact, they assert that no woman has this right. No woman can speak to the definition of womanhood. No woman can claim her experience—as an embodied female, as a daughter, or as a sister, or a wife, or a mother—as content of what it means to be a woman. That experience, by the above logic, is that particular woman’s alone and doesn’t define womanhood. After all, none of that seems to be content of the experience of “womanhood” the bearded individuals in this clip have for themselves. And so, that other woman and her experience, along with her definition of womanhood, needs to be nullified, silenced. Because trans activists are unable to define their terms, none of the rest of us are allowed to define ours, and women least of all.

Tags: gender ideologyLGBT ideologyLGBT+Transgenderism
Joseph Grabowski

Joseph Grabowski

Joseph Grabowski was the Executive Director of the International Organization for the Family until August 2022. He also served as Director of Communications for the National Organization for Marriage. Joseph has a B.A. in Philosophy from Saint Charles Borromeo Seminary, Overbrook and M.A. in English from Marquette University.  Joe has appeared as an expert on traditional marriage and family in local and nationwide media, including The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Boston Globe, Breitbart, and elsewhere. Joe’s writings on traditional marriage and family, as well as on Catholic Social Teaching and the writings of G. K. Chesterton and Hilaire Belloc, have appeared in The Stream, Gilbert Magazine, Ethika Politika, and The Distributist Review, and he has spoken at several national conferences on the place of G.K. Chesterton in 20th Century literature and thought.

Discussion about this post

Popular News

  • Most important meeting of pro-family leaders in 2023 held at the UN

    Most important meeting of pro-family leaders in 2023 held at the UN

    32 shares 55 VIEWS
    Share 0 Tweet 32
  • Priest attacked in Santiago de Compostela Cathedral

    15 shares 45 VIEWS
    Share 15 Tweet 0
  • Defects, limitations and differences: an essential key to family harmony

    32 shares 5 VIEWS
    Share 0 Tweet 32

IFN – International Family News Network

© 2022 IFN – International Family News - All Rights Reserved.

Quick Links

  • About iFamNews
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Life
  • Family
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Shows
  • Petitions
  • Subscribe
  • Donate

  • en English
  • it Italiano
  • es Español
  • fr Français
  • de Deutsch
  • pl Polski
  • sr српски
  • ru Русский
  • Login
  • Sign Up

© 2022 IFN – International Family News - All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Subscribe