• Latest
  • All
Justice Sotomayor’s advice to law students should be heeded by every Supreme Court justice, including Sotomayor

Justice Sotomayor’s advice to law students should be heeded by every Supreme Court justice, including Sotomayor

November 2, 2021
Former Louisville University professor wins $1.6 million over dismissal for criticism of transgender treatments for children

Former Louisville University professor wins $1.6 million over dismissal for criticism of transgender treatments for children

April 26, 2025
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license. Author: Alfredo Borba

Pope Francis passed away at the age of 88

April 21, 2025
Author: Tom Morris

U.K. Supreme Court defines woman based on biological sex

April 16, 2025
New Colorado bill punishes moms and dads for rejecting trans ideology

New Colorado bill punishes moms and dads for rejecting trans ideology

April 5, 2025
Female fencer Stephanie Turner faces penalties for refusal to compete against transgender opponent

Female fencer Stephanie Turner faces penalties for refusal to compete against transgender opponent

April 3, 2025
Georgia Governor to sign Riley Gaines Act of 2025, safeguarding women’s sports from transgender ideology

Georgia Governor to sign Riley Gaines Act of 2025, safeguarding women’s sports from transgender ideology

April 2, 2025
Humanity’s indispensable but unsung heroes

Humanity’s indispensable but unsung heroes

March 18, 2025
AfD politician slams leftist abortion agenda in staunchly pro-life speech

AfD politician slams leftist abortion agenda in staunchly pro-life speech

March 12, 2025
Maine locals rally against Governor Mills’ stance on transgender participation in sports

Maine locals rally against Governor Mills’ stance on transgender participation in sports

March 1, 2025
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

J.D. Vance criticizes Europe’s disregard for pro-life advocates and religious freedom at Munich Security Conference

February 20, 2025
  • About iFamNews
  • Contact

Navigation Button Subscribe

  • Subscribe
May 12, 2025
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
  • English
    • Italiano
    • Español
    • Français
    • Deutsch
    • Polski
    • српски
    • Русский
    • Hrvatski

Navigation Button Donate

  • Donate
International Family News Network (IFN)
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Life
  • Family
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Shows
  • Petitions
  • Subscribe
  • Donate
International Family News Network (IFN)
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Life
  • Family
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Shows
  • Petitions
  • Subscribe
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
International Family News Network (IFN)
No Result
View All Result

Justice Sotomayor’s advice to law students should be heeded by every Supreme Court justice, including Sotomayor

Frank Schubert by Frank Schubert
November 2, 2021
in Foreground, Opinion
341
Reading Time: 3 mins read
0
Justice Sotomayor’s advice to law students should be heeded by every Supreme Court justice, including Sotomayor
Share on FacebookShare on WhatsAppShare on TelegramShare on TwitterShare on WeChat

Supreme Court justice Sonia Sotomayor increasingly finds herself in a frustrating position, being a liberal on an increasingly conservative US Supreme Court. When the Supreme Court declined a few weeks ago to strike down a pro-life law enacted by the state of Texas, the so-called Texas Heartbeat Law, she issued a rancorous and pointed dissent, writing that the law was “clearly unconstitutional” and her conservative colleagues “have opted to bury their heads in the sand.” Such heated rhetoric is not terribly unusual for justices in a losing position. Conservative icon Antonin Scalia, who battled a liberal Supreme Court majority for years, was famous for his pointed dissents in important cases.

At the time, I dismissed Sotomayor’s opinion without much hesitation as I almost never agree with her on matters of ideology or philosophy. But comments she made recently about this same Texas abortion case caught my attention. Surprisingly I found myself in wholehearted agreement with what she said, although not in the way she intended.

Speaking to law school students at an event sponsored by the American Bar Association just a few days before the current US Supreme Court term commenced, Justice Sotomayor said this of the Texas abortion case: “You know, I can’t change Texas’s law. But you can, and everyone else who may or may not like it can go out there and be lobbying forces in changing laws that you don’t like.”

I could not agree with her more. Sotomayor has unwittingly just articulated the proper position of Supreme Court jurists and underscored the fundamental flaw in the Supreme Court’s approach to abortion jurisprudence for much of the last fifty years. Judges are not legislators. They are not to legislate from the bench. Their job is to interpret the law and the constitution as it was written, not as they would like it to be. They don’t get to write laws.

When the US Supreme Court created a federal “right” to abortion in Roe v Wade in 1973, they acted as legislators, not jurists. They invented – legislated from the bench – a constitutional right that did not exist. It did not exist then, and it does not exist now. The regulation of abortion is simply not found in the US constitution. It is a matter left to the states to decide.

Likely in the next few days, the US Supreme Court will determine how the Texas heartbeat law should be considered by the courts, but the Texas law is not where the issue of abortion will be decided. That will be in the Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health Organization case, which ifamnews.com has covered extensively (See for example here, here and here.)

The Dobbs case is a full, frontal challenge to the US Supreme Court’s abortion jurisprudence, first created (legislated) in Roe, and then recrafted (amended) in Planned Parenthood v Casey. In Dobbs, the state of Mississippi asks the Supreme Court to correct its grave error in Roe and Casey and to rule that, in fact, there is no constitutional right to abortion. Instead, it is up to Mississippi legislators and elected officials to determine how to regulate abortion in Mississippi, just as it is up to elected officials in Texas to decide abortion law in their state, and elected officials in California and New York to decide abortion law in their respective states. California and New York will no doubt regulate abortion much differently than will Texas and Mississippi, but that is the beauty of the federalist system created by our nation’s founders.

Briefing in the Dobbs case is already complete. Oral argument is scheduled for December 1, 2021. A ruling is expected sometime in 2022, very likely when the term comes to a conclusion in June.

When they reach their decision in the Dobbs case, every justice on the US Supreme Court, including Justice Sotomayor herself, should keep in mind the wisdom of the advice that Sotomayor shared with those law school students a few weeks back. Justices can’t write laws. They are not legislators. They are not to legislate from the bench. It is up to the American people to, as Justice Sotomayor so wisely observed, “go out there and be lobbying forces in changing laws.”

Let us hope that she and her colleagues have the courage to take her words to heart.

Tags: Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health OrganizationJustice Sonia SotomayorMississippiNew YorkPlanned Parenthood v. CaseyRoe v. WadeTexas heartbeat lawUS Supreme Court
Frank Schubert

Frank Schubert

Frank Schubert is a communications consultant for the International Organization for the Family (IOF) and has twice been named America’s top public affairs professional. Schubert serves a similar role for the National Organization for Marriage (NOM). He has worked extensively on family-related issues including supporting marriage, the sanctity of human life and religious liberty, among other issues. Schubert is one of the country’s top experts in managing ballot initiative campaigns and has won over 50 such campaigns in over one-dozen states, compiling an 80% winning record. He managed the successful Proposition 8 campaign in California as well as subsequent winning campaigns on marriage in Maine and North Carolina. His views on issues have been widely reported by the national and international media and he has been interviewed by news organizations hundreds of times. He is the founder of Inspiration Strategies, a public affairs firm.

Discussion about this post

Popular News

  • The new Pope is Robert Prevost, and his name will be Leo XIV. He continues to be denounced in Peru for covering up sexual abuse by priests.

    The new Pope is Robert Prevost, and his name will be Leo XIV. He continues to be denounced in Peru for covering up sexual abuse by priests.

    0 shares 28 VIEWS
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Two Spanish ministers denounced for embezzlement in contracts awarded to Tragsa

    0 shares 23 VIEWS
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Christian Lawyers request to the City Council of Callosa (Alicante) the replacement of the cross after confirming that the re-signified crosses do not violate the Law of Historical Memory.

    0 shares 13 VIEWS
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • A judge in Tortosa (Catalonia) investigates the procession of the “Santa Baldana” that brought out the virgin surrounded by black pudding.

    0 shares 11 VIEWS
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Habemus Papam! Fumata blanca: first article of the new pontificate of Esperanza

    0 shares 11 VIEWS
    Share 0 Tweet 0

IFN – International Family News Network

© 2022 IFN – International Family News - All Rights Reserved.

Quick Links

  • About iFamNews
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Us

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Subscribe

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Life
  • Family
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Shows
  • Petitions
  • Subscribe
  • Donate

  • en English
  • it Italiano
  • es Español
  • fr Français
  • de Deutsch
  • pl Polski
  • sr српски
  • ru Русский
  • hr Hrvatski
  • Login
  • Sign Up

© 2022 IFN – International Family News - All Rights Reserved.