• Latest
  • All
No, the Nuclear Family is Not a “Mistake”

No, the Nuclear Family is Not a “Mistake”

March 10, 2020
The Brian Brown Show #4 – Levan Vasadze – Back from the Brink of Death

The Brian Brown Show #4 – Levan Vasadze – Back from the Brink of Death

October 3, 2023
suicidio

Reflections on youth suicide

October 2, 2023
Complaint to European Commission against Spain for abusive use of abortion law with repeat abortions

Complaint to European Commission against Spain for abusive use of abortion law with repeat abortions

October 2, 2023
Texas Attorney General sues Yelp for misleading language on pro-life centers

Texas Attorney General sues Yelp for misleading language on pro-life centers

September 28, 2023
Newsom signs law protecting doctors providing abortion pills by mail in restricted states

Newsom signs law protecting doctors providing abortion pills by mail in restricted states

September 28, 2023
UK Lottery funds Just Like Us charity with more than 0.5 mn euros

UK Lottery funds Just Like Us charity with more than 0.5 mn euros

September 28, 2023
Berlin government officials offer a book on prostitution to children

Berlin government officials offer a book on prostitution to children

September 28, 2023
Germany: 7,000 people attend March for Life  

Germany: 7,000 people attend March for Life  

September 27, 2023
Italy: National Institute of Health issues shocking LGBT guidance against women and children

Italy: National Institute of Health issues shocking LGBT guidance against women and children

September 27, 2023
Pro-life pregnancy centers challenge Vermont law restricting services and free speech rights

Pro-life pregnancy centers challenge Vermont law restricting services and free speech rights

September 26, 2023
  • About iFamNews
  • Contact

Navigation Button Subscribe

  • Subscribe
October 4, 2023
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
  • English
    • Italiano
    • Español
    • Français
    • Deutsch
    • Polski
    • српски
    • Русский

Navigation Button Donate

  • Donate
International Family News Network (IFN)
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Life
  • Family
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Shows
  • Petitions
  • Subscribe
  • Donate
International Family News Network (IFN)
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Life
  • Family
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Shows
  • Petitions
  • Subscribe
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
International Family News Network (IFN)
No Result
View All Result

No, the Nuclear Family is Not a “Mistake”

A series of experts respond to David Brooks' recent controversial article in The Atlantic.

Nicole King by Nicole King
March 10, 2020
in Family, Foreground
1.2k
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0
No, the Nuclear Family is Not a “Mistake”
Share on FacebookShare on WhatsAppShare on TelegramShare on TwitterShare on WeChat

The author and New York Times columnist David Brooks made waves in the March 2020 issue of The Atlantic, where he argued that “The Nuclear Family Was A Mistake.”

Brooks’ argument runs thus: In previous centuries, mankind lived not in nuclear families of parents and children, but in large, extended kin networks. These kin, he argues, were not necessarily related by blood—some were the people you hunted with, and some were the people you migrated with. Fast forward several thousand years. “Through the early parts of American history,” Brooks continues, “most people lived in what, by today’s standards, were big, sprawling households.” The Industrial Revolution changed all of that, as individual men and women fled the farm, and their families, to pursue life in the big city. When these men and women formed families, they were not the big, sprawling kin networks of old. Rather, they were nuclear families—two parents, with children.

But the nuclear family, Brooks argues, is “inherently fragile.” It worked briefly, in a historical blip from roughly 1950-1965, but has been falling apart ever since. Whereas extended families “have two great strengths.” “The first,” Brooks continues, “is resilience. An extended family is one or more families in a supporting web.” When one relationship falls apart—someone leaves, or divorces, or a relationship is strained—there are grandparents, cousins, uncles, etc. to step in and take care of any children. There are people there to fill the gaps. Brooks continues, “The second great strength of extended families is their socializing force.” Children have numerous adults to look up to for education and moral instruction.

But those families are gone, and the nuclear family is in crisis. What are we to do? Brooks’ solution is “forged families”—“In reaction to family chaos,” he writes, “accumulating evidence suggests, the prioritization of family is beginning to make a comeback. Americans are experimenting with new forms of kinship and extended family in search of stability.” Part of this “comeback,” he believes, is truly a return to prior ways, as more Americans are now living in multigenerational homes than before—many of them adult children returning to live with parents, and aging parents moving in with children. But some of this movement looks a bit different. Brooks writes, “The past several years have seen the rise of new living arrangements that bring nonbiological kin into family or familylike [sic] relationships.” He documents networks of single mothers who share spaces and childcare duties, co-housing communities for young parents, or other co-housing units where residents share some common meals and duties but have private spaces. “For decades we have been eating at smaller and smaller tables, with fewer and fewer kin,” Brooks closes. “It’s time to find ways to bring back the big tables.”

This lengthy essay had its controversial moments, and the Institute for Family Studies published six separate responses to it. Many of these responses share common themes.

Wendy Wang and W. Bradford Wilcox point out that yes, more Americans are now living in multigenerational homes, but data show that “Adults who live with their parents are less happy than others.” And similar research shows that parents are happier when their adult children leave the house. Scott Stanely wonders, “how many elderly Americans want to have less autonomy and live with their kin?” Many, he continues, “cling to their autonomy and will fight to keep it until reality forces them to do otherwise.”

Andrew Cherlin and Kay Hymowitz both point out research that flies in the face of David Brooks’ historical narrative. “Scholars now pretty much agree,” Hymowitz writes, “that the nuclear family household has been the ‘dominant form’ in Western Europe and the United States since the dawn of the industrial era.” There is something innate in men and women alike that leads them to form pair bonds, which she calls the “inextinguishable human urge for pair bonding.” Furthermore, she continues, “In data published in a 1994 paper, [Steven] Ruggles estimated that as of 1880, more than two-thirds of white couples, the large majority with children, lived in independent households. The anomaly was the extended family, not the nuclear family.” Cherlin agrees: “in the past, white families were rarely centered on large family groups.” And he believes that Brooks’ “forged families” have their own fragility problems: “These kinship ties are easier to break because they are voluntary; neither strong norms nor laws stand in the way of ending them.”

Richard Reeves agrees with Brooks that “both the quality and the quantity of our relationships matter,” and continues, “The idea of a “chosen” family is consistent with the development of modern liberalism, in which relationships are contingent rather than coerced.” And Rod Dreher cites the decline in religious commitment for the failure of the family. “One can only hope for [forged families’] success,” but without religious commitment, it seems doubtful.”

So where are we left, after all of that? The authors all agree that the nuclear family is on the decline, and this presents problems—mostly for children. They all agree that unfettered desire for personal autonomy and freedom has made families more fragile, and again, life for children harder.

But many of the experts at the Institute for Family Studies contend that in calling the nuclear family a “mistake,” Brooks is missing rather a lot.

Tags: familythe natural family
Nicole King

Nicole King

Nicole M. King is the Managing Editor of IOF's journal, The Natural Family: An International Journal of Research and Policy, the United States’ leading journal of family-policy research. In that capacity, she writes, edits and corresponds with editors and contributors to ensure that each issue provides the most relevant and accurate research and policy analysis available. Nicole holds a B.A. in English as well as M.A.s in English and Political Theory. She has contributed to The Front Porch Republic and Chronicles: A Magazine of American Culture, among others. She is also a contributing editor to SALVO Magazine and a blogger at salvomag.com.

Discussion about this post

Popular News

  • Million Person March: Canadians bravely stand up for children, oppose gender indoctrination in schools

    Million Person March: Canadians bravely stand up for children, oppose gender indoctrination in schools

    1 shares 553 VIEWS
    Share 1 Tweet 0
  • Literature and music are being used for spreading ideological propaganda

    32 shares 527 VIEWS
    Share 0 Tweet 32
  • Berlin government officials offer a book on prostitution to children

    1 shares 495 VIEWS
    Share 1 Tweet 0
  • Italy: National Institute of Health issues shocking LGBT guidance against women and children

    1 shares 328 VIEWS
    Share 1 Tweet 0
  • Dog identity

    1 shares 299 VIEWS
    Share 1 Tweet 0

IFN – International Family News Network

© 2022 IFN – International Family News - All Rights Reserved.

Quick Links

  • About iFamNews
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Life
  • Family
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Science
  • Shows
  • Petitions
  • Subscribe
  • Donate

  • en English
  • it Italiano
  • es Español
  • fr Français
  • de Deutsch
  • pl Polski
  • sr српски
  • ru Русский
  • Login
  • Sign Up

© 2022 IFN – International Family News - All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Subscribe